As recently as 21st June the York Council said that it hadn’t been given the results of COVID 19 tests carried out at the Poppleton Park and Ride testing centre.
The centre had opened on 24th April. Almost immediately there were claims that the test results for local centres “were disappearing into a black hole”. Around 5000 tests were carried out during the first 10 days of operation of the new centre. Officials remained tight lipped about the outcomes. Local MPs were urged to lift the blanket of confidentiality and some local reporters also lobbied for more openness
Yesterday, the local York Director of Health confirmed to the media that they had received the figures.
She revealed that as of June 27 there were 424 positive coronavirus tests confirmed through, what is known as, the “Pillar 2” testing programme. Added to the lab test reports already published, that meant that there had been a total of 887 cases in the City.
Significantly there were nine positive test results recorded through Pillar 2 data in the past week.
The Council didn’t say how well its contact tracing service was performing.
The Financial Times has said that Pillar 2 results now comprise the largest proportion of positive tests across the country
This is the latest in a series of communications failures by central and local government. It was several weeks into to crisis before daily updates were provided on deaths and test results (Pillar 1) . Both sets of stats are now updated at Council/Hospital Trust level each day.
The absence of data from the commercial test sites and home testing means that residents still have only a partial picture.
It is not surprising that there were many positive results at Poppleton. The centre initially started out testing key workers and then moved on to test those who were suffering from COVID symptoms.
What is extraordinary is that it has taken so long for a glimpse of the results to leak out.
We have seen a copy of an email in which a Council official had yesterday said to a resident
“Although we now have access to pillar 2 data, as a council we are not allowed to publish it. It is to be used for internal planning purposes only”.
A couple of hours later, the Council was forced to release a comment after the figures were leaked.
Some other Councils are believed to be routinely publishing the information while MPs are now also being briefed. They may be the source of the leaked information
Whatever the source, the time has come for the Council leadership to allay growing concerns that the secrecy covering this issue has a sinister motive.
The infection rate in York is below the regional and national averages. That is good news which should be shared
The Council must agree to update residents on the progress being made in tracing the contacts of the recently revealed cases.
They must also ensure that local daily briefings on all test results (Pillars 1,2,3 and 4) are made public and quickly.