Residents views and safety risks ignored as planning Councillors back Arts Barge plan.

Sad to see the City’s planning committee rejected professional advice last night when they gave the go ahead to mooring an “Arts Barge” near Tower Gardens.

The plan was approved by 11 votes to 4.

It means that the Council has – subject to a license being granted – agreed to the provision of another alcohol based leisure facility on a river which has already claimed the lives of 7 people in recent years. All those that have died were to a lesser or greater extent intoxicated.

Residents had been concerned about the visual effect the barge would have on the appearance of the historic core. There were also fears about noise  generation at, and near, the venue.

However the main controversy remains the liability of taxpayers for the high risk venture.

It remains unclear how much the barge operators will pay in rent (license fee)  for  a mooring in what is a prime City centre location. In many cities moorings of this sort are auctioned with fees starting at £3000 pa. ..more for commercial sites. In theory Business Rates would also be payable but these could be reduced if the facility is operated by a Trust or under a  similar legal arrangement.

The crunch will now come when an application for a premises license is submitted. The Council has shown little backbone in resisting additional applications for drinking establishments even where they breech the City centre cumulative impact policy (see below).

Following the approval of an unsuitable design for a visitor centre at Clifford’s Tower – and the Council’s Executive committee seemingly intent on dropping ugly shipping containers onto a site in Piccadilly – City centre residents must be wondering who they can turn to for support.

York Council’s policy on licensing in the central area

“Arts Barge” mooring plan set to be torpedoed

arts bargeThe long running saga of the York Arts barge looks like it will take another twist next week when the Council’s Planning committee is being recommended to reject a proposal to moor the vessel next to Tower Gardens.

Council officials rightly point out that the barge would impact on the Conservation area affecting views of several historic buildings.

The plan has attracted many objections from residents (and a similar number from supporters) who fear both the visual intrusion of the barge and the possible anti-social implications of providing yet another venue serving alcohol in what is already a problem area.

Ironically the York Civic Trust, which should be advancing the case for conservation of the built environment, says it supports the plan! The same organisation recently came out in favour of the bizarre plan to use storage containers as the basis of a new development on Piccadilly. Its opposition to the visitor centre planned for Clifford’s Tower was also luke warm.

Proposed arts barge location

Proposed arts barge location

In the final analysis planning experts ask the very reasonable question why a new arts venue could not be accommodated in an existing building. There are several venues in the City which are under-used.

The controversy about the Arts Barge project started in the last decade when the, then Labour controlled, Council agreed to use taxpayer’s money to underwrite the project.

Fortunately, the current coalition run Council have been much more circumspect about risking taxpayer’s money.

The report on the proposal can be read by clicking here