York residents can now see for the first time a copy of the damming report produced on the Council by the Local Government Association.
Although worded in diplomatic, conciliatory language it confirms the view held by many residents.
Namely that the new Labour administration elected in 2011 metaphorically threw away the rule book as they tried to implement a, hopelessly overambitious, programme of change against a background of falling resource levels.
Relationships within the Council broke down and inexperienced Councillors – catapulted into key decision making roles – had neither the confidence nor inclination to seek consensus support for their proposals.
Secrecy became a byword, denying residents the opportunity to contribute before decisions were taken.
There were complaints of bullying.
Councillors tried to “micro manage” – distracting staff from their principal responsibilities
The problem was exacerbated by the Council Leadership who tried to fully exploit the Councils public relations machine to justify their partisan views.
The report also criticises outside “commentators” (people using social media sites and “twitter” to criticise) and describes the number of FOI requests as being unreasonably high.
However the number of FOI requests increased after 2011 simply because access to performance data – freely available in earlier years – was hidden by the new administration
The report is being considered by the Councils Governance committee on Thursday
The LGA team make several suggestions about how a more constructive way forward can be developed.
Until the extraordinary events at the “urgency” meeting held 10 days ago – together with the more recent power grab by senior officials – that was a worthy opportunity which seemed to have some chance of success.
But clearly confrontation is likely to increase in the run up to the elections in May and it seems increasingly likely that the election of a new Council will be needed before the unhappy events of the last 4 years can finally be confined to history.
Electors will not make the same mistake again.
They will be looking for candidates (of whatever party) who have a mature outlook on life, relevant experience, a proven commitment to York and the neighbourhood which they seek to represent. as well as a record of putting the City ahead of political ambitions..