“York Council breached Freedom of Information law” – Information Commissioner’s decision

The Information Commissioners Office has ruled that the York Council breached Freedom of information legislation when it refused to reveal how many “All York” bus tickets’ had been sold in the City.

Page 1 click to enlarge

Page 1 click to enlarge

Page 2 click to enlarge

Page 2 click to enlarge


Page 3 click to enlarge

Page 3 click to enlarge

Page 4 click to enlarge

Page 4 click to enlarge


The decision notice will be published on the Commissioners web site shortly.

The case dates back 12 months to a time when the York Council announced that it was planning to subsidise a new bus ticket which would allow passengers to travel on services provided by more than one operator.

The Council allocated £20,000 of taxpayers money to fund the launch and then agreed to resource the backroom apportionment work involved in distributing fare income to bus operators.

The option was labelled an All York ticket. They were priced at £5 for an adult.

The Council were subsequently asked to indicate how many of the tickets had actually being sold?

The Council declined to disclose the information on the grounds that it was “commercially confidential”.

However, the Information Commissioner has now confirmed that the aggregated sales figures cannot be regarded as confidential as they don’t reveal the number of sales made by each bus company.

He has ordered the Council to release the sales figures.

The decision notice reads,

“The Commissioners decision is that the City of York Council has failed to demonstrate that section 41(1) of the Freedom of Information Act is engaged.

The Commissioner requires the public authority to take the following steps to ensure compliance with the legislation –

• Disclose the information to the complainant”

Former Council Leader Steve Galloway, who raised the issue last year, commented,

“The mistake concerned one of several outstanding issues that bus passengers in York have with the Council.

The most serious of these is a failure to publish, on a regular basis, reliability information on local bus services.

Hopefully the Council will now side with passengers in their quest for timely information about bus service operations in the City”.

3 thoughts on ““York Council breached Freedom of Information law” – Information Commissioner’s decision

  1. Matthew Laverack says:

    York Council is obsessed with secrecy. It persistently uses “confidentiality” and “draft” as an excuse to deny information which it should willingly divulge. It breaches both the letter and the spirit of the Law in relation to Freedom of Information.

    If they were more open and transparent in the first place they wouldn’t be deluged with so many FOI requests.

  2. […] months after a Freedom of Information request was lodged with the York Council, officials have finally revealed the number of “All […]

  3. […] months after a Freedom of Information request was lodged with the York Council, officials have finally revealed the number of “All […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.